NBC Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
NBC Insider The Voice

A Fan Favorite Season 1 Artist Just Returned to The Voice & Got 2 Chair Turns

If at first you don't succeed, regroup and try again.

By Cassidy Ward
Michael Bublé's 6-Year-Old Daughter Is Snoop Dogg's Biggest Fan
Video thumbnail
Now Playing
5:47
Highlight
Michael Bublé's 6-Year-Old Daughter Is Snoop Dogg's Biggest Fan
Video thumbnail
11:02
Web Exclusive
Trump Wants Canada as 51st State, Elon Musk’s Condom Claims: Late Night's News of the Week
Video thumbnail
2:37
Highlight
Senate Confirms RFK Jr. as U.S. Health Secretary
Video thumbnail
9:32
Highlight
Harper Steele Got Jay-Z a Real Joint for His SNL Sketch with Will Ferrell
Video thumbnail
13:05
Highlight
Tom Hanks Still Remembers His Subway Surfing Song from His Cut SNL Sketch
Video thumbnail
8:36
Web Exclusive
CORRECTIONS Episode 130: Week of Monday, February 10
Video thumbnail
12:01
Highlight
Musk Slammed by Warren at Protest Over DOGE Cuts; Trump's Kennedy Center Takeover: A Closer Look
Video thumbnail
10:58
Highlight
Emily Spivey Sings a Song from Cut SNL Sketch, Shares Her Favorite Host Memories
Video thumbnail
3:15
Highlight
Elon Musk Addresses False Claims About Sending $50 Million of Condoms to Gaza
Video thumbnail
12:55
Highlight
Jon Hamm Jokingly Told Amy Poehler to "Pull It Together" During His First SNL Show
Video thumbnail
10:49
Highlight
Musk & Trump Grilled Over DOGE Cuts in Oval Office; MAGA's Greenland Name Change Bill: A Closer Look
Video thumbnail
4:43
Highlight
Seth Holds a Surprise Inspection of His Monologue Writers in February 2025
Video thumbnail
8:38
Highlight
Mikey Madison Finally Sees the Anora Menorah from Sarah Sherman's Cut SNL Sketch
Video thumbnail
11:30
Highlight
Bill Murray Talks About Apologizing on Saturday Night Live for Not Being Funny
Video thumbnail
7:16
Highlight
James Anderson Pitches His Failed Saturday Night Live Sketch Ideas
Video thumbnail
2:28
Highlight
Wally the Cue Card Guy Shows Seth His Daily Routine in Partnership with Ray-Ban Meta
Video thumbnail
8:47
Highlight
Trader Joe's Will Limit Egg Purchases
Video thumbnail
2:19
Highlight
Trump Says He’s Serious About Canada Becoming the 51st State

Season 1 of The Voice hit airwaves on April 26, 2011, with Coaches Adam Levine, CeeLo Green, Christina Aguilera, and Blake Shelton. The show has evolved over the course of 13 years and 26 seasons, but the basic premise and the dream that fuels it remains the same. 

How to Watch

Watch The Voice on Mondays and Tuesdays at 8/7c on NBC and next day on Peacock. 

Rewatch the pilot and you’ll see 20-year-old Kelsey Rey among the Blind Auditions. Rey sang “American Boy” by Estelle and earned a Three-Chair Turn from Levine, Aguilera, and Green. She ended up on Team CeeLo and was eliminated in the Battles, singing Natasha Bedingfield’s “Unwritten” against The Thompson Sisters. That ended her career on The Voice, but not forever. Now, with more than a decade of extra life and performing experience, she returns, rebranded as Felsmere, for another shot at glory.

Felsmere (a.k.a Kelsey Rey) sings “Some Kind of Wonderful” during The Voice Blind Auditions

Felsmere performs onstage

“In Season 1, I was young and timid. I’m coming in with a new sound, and I hope the Coaches love it,” Felsmere said, before taking to the stage. Her performance began in darkness, almost as if the singing to the Coaches’ backs wasn’t secret enough, as she delivered a vibrant rendition of “Some Kind of Wonderful.”

RELATED: The Voice Season 26 Blind Auditions (September 23): Every Chair Turn

“I actually was on the first season of The Voice,” Felsmere confessed after her Blind Audition wrapped. “CeeLo, Adam, and Christina turned for me. I was eliminated after the Battle round, but I learned so much only being 20 years old. It was the best experience of my life.” Since Felsmere left Season 1 of The Voice, she’s spent her time writing and producing music, leveling up for her triumphant return.

Michael Bublé was the first Coach to turn, zeroing in on Felsmere’s smoky, jazz-influenced vocals. Gwen Stefani followed soon thereafter. Felsmere earned a Two-Chair Turn, but it was almost three (with Snoop Dogg apparently refraining for strategic reasons). 

“I’m always trying to find people who have big dreams that I already lived, that I can Coach and figure out how to find their identity through these songs. I feel like it would be so amazing for me to hang out with you, to figure out who you are, and I’d love to have you on Team Gwen,” Stefani said.

RELATED: Every Winner of The Voice From Season 1 Through Season 25

“You have this kind of jazzy thing going. That, to me, means that you can stride between the pop world and the jazz world. You’re perfect with your runs. You have a really sweet tone. Whoever you choose, you’re going to be great on this show,” Bublé said. 

Ultimately, Felsmere chose Team Gwen. “Felsmere came to Season 1 of The Voice, and now she’s back for Season 26,” Stefani said. “Everything she was trying, she was landing. She’s consistent and her tone is just undeniable. I’m really excited to pick songs for her.

Sponsored Stories
Recommended by Zergnet