NBC Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
NBC Insider The Traitors

The Traitors Winners on Their Unique Finale, Danielle's Fake Tears & Gabby's Wedding

Keeping their win a secret was surprisingly easy, as they revealed during their March 10 Tonight Show appearance. 

By Christopher Rudolph
The Traitors Season 3 Winners Talk Keeping Their Win a Secret, Gabby's Vegas Wedding & Tom Sandoval
Video thumbnail
Now Playing
5:34
Highlight
The Traitors Season 3 Winners Talk Keeping Their Win a Secret, Gabby's Vegas Wedding & Tom Sandoval
Video thumbnail
38:00
Web Exclusive
Parker Posey, Jason Isaacs, Patrick Schwarzenegger and More Talk The White Lotus Season 3
Video thumbnail
6:20
Highlight
Charades with Jon Hamm, Patrick Schwarzenegger, Hannah Berner and Paige DeSorbo
Video thumbnail
7:22
Highlight
Hannah Berner and Paige DeSorbo Found Out About Their Past Lives During a Traumatic Psychic Reading
Video thumbnail
9:54
Highlight
Jon Hamm Talks Meryl Streep's First SNL Sketch, His SNL50 Seat Filler and Your Friends and Neighbors
Video thumbnail
3:16
Highlight
Alex Warren: Ordinary
Video thumbnail
8:57
Highlight
Trump Signs Order to Make Showers Great Again, Admits Fear of a Depression Led to Tariff Pause
Video thumbnail
6:34
Highlight
Patrick Schwarzenegger Refused to Spoil The White Lotus, Shows Jimmy How to Make a Protein Shake
Video thumbnail
6:30
Highlight
Tom Cruise Insisted Rami Malek Get Weapons Training for The Amateur
Video thumbnail
1:19
Highlight
Paige Bueckers Brings UCONN's National Championship Trophy to The Tonight Show
Video thumbnail
3:27
Highlight
Warren Zeiders: You For A Reason
Video thumbnail
11:10
Highlight
Jason Isaacs Reveals How He Nailed His White Lotus Accent, Talks Making Lucius Malfoy's Iconic Look
Video thumbnail
8:41
Highlight
Zarna Garg Posted a Personal Ad to Find a Husband, Talks A Nice Indian Boy (Extended)
Video thumbnail
9:37
Highlight
Stocks Skyrocket as Trump Announces 90-Day Tariff Pause, Tells Americans to "Be Cool"
Video thumbnail
9:39
Highlight
Triple H Was Surprised with WWE Hall of Fame, Talks WrestleMania Debut and John Cena's Farewell Tour
Video thumbnail
4:09
Highlight
CA7RIEL & Paco Amoroso: EL DÍA DEL AMIGO
Video thumbnail
3:13
Highlight
Tonight Show Shoutouts: Puerto Rico, Eye Exams and Pinky Promises
Video thumbnail
6:40
Highlight
Gigi Hadid Reveals Silver Bob Was a Wig, Talks Medieval Times with Her Daughter & Guest In Residence

Gabby Windey, Dylan Efron, Dolores Catania and Lord Ivar Mountbatten were the final Faithfuls standing in The Traitors Season 3 finale — and keeping quiet about their stunning victory was surprisingly easy.

How to Watch

Watch The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on NBC weeknights at 11:35/10:35c and next day on Peacock

"Is it hard to keep it secret when you know that you won? Is everyone asking you what's going on?" Jimmy Fallon asked the Faithful foursome when they appeared on The Tonight Show on March 10.

"Nobody wants spoilers of the show, but I have a big mouth, so I want to tell everyone," Windey told Fallon. "I'm like, 'Please ask me who won!,' but they don't want to know."

RELATED: How Much Money Was in the Final Prize Pot on The Traitors Season 3?

Would The Traitors Season 3 winners return for an All-Stars season?

Would the reigning winners be up for returning to Alan Cumming's regal Scottish castle if an All-Stars season of the show came to fruition?

"Yes," answered Catania, as Efron added, "I would, in a heartbeat."

As for Windey, she "can't say" at the moment. "There's not enough time that's passed. I don't know. I need a break," she admitted. Fair, but we think it would be hard to resist if Cumming were to come calling again.

Dylan Efron on Danielle Reyes' dramatic fake Traitors tears

They might have lived The Traitors — but watching the show back was a different experience, as Efron explained during his Tonight Show visit.

"Oh, so much is different. So much more intense than you think. Everyone thinks it's so easy to get a Traitor," he said. "We're not clueing in like you see on TV. When it's on Danielle and she's doing those fake tears. We don't see all that. Like, I was looking at my breakfast. I wasn't looking at everybody's reactions."

The winners of “The Traitors” Season 3 all talk to Jimmy on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon Season 12, Episode 81

How are The Traitors selected?

One of the most stressful moments on the show is when Cumming chooses who will be a Traitor: He does it by walking around the Round Table and tapping his picks on their shoulder.

What viewers don't see is that The Traitors Host actually walks around multiple times, dialing up the drama with every turn.

"The taps are so light, so actually you don't realize, but you're honestly thinking... [you were]," recalled Mountbatten.

"The worst part is he walks around more than 20 times! You see maybe three times on TV. It goes on and on," revealed Efron.

"So the stress of that, like, 'This is the time,'" added Catania. "You could feel the wind of him going by."

RELATED: Can You Visit The Traitors Castle? Everything to Know About Ardross Castle

Gabby Windey married Robby Hoffman after winning The Traitors Season 3

In The Traitors Season 3 finale, Cumming asked the remaining players what they would do with the prize money. In a surprisingly emotional moment, Windey told him she would use the winnings to marry her girlfriend, actor and stand-up comedian Robby Hoffman.

Windey kept true to her promise, and had a whirlwind wedding in Las Vegas, which she told Fallon she "cannot recommend enough."

Robby Hoffman and Gabby Windey pose together ont he red carpet for the 2023 iHeartRadio Music Festival

"$799 for the deluxe package. A limo," she detailed. "Reverend Nature. Big Nate took all the photos. They're gorgeous. Not interested, but would recommend. 10 out of 10."

Congrats to Windey on the marriage, and to all four of The Traitors winners!