Abby gets more than she bargained for when she offers to help Wyatt’s friend stay sober for the night. Dan and Julianne battle for the best prize in Gurgs’ annual evidence locker lottery.

Abby’s friendship with her ex-boyfriend’s mother leads to romantic complications. When Julianne’s wealthy aunt passes away, the gang vies for a piece of her inheritance.

Dan goes up against Julianne to defend the Wheelers and his professional reputation. Abby’s love life takes an exciting turn when she meets a handsome man in the courthouse, but there’s a catch.

At the behest of producer Sy Hoffman, Dan and Abby work together to turn Dan’s memoir into a musical. Wyatt tries to help Julianne stay cool when her ex-lover turns up at the courthouse.

Harry’s old magician’s assistant appears in the courthouse and puts Dan and Abby in a tough position. Gurgs, Flobert and Julianne are determined to fire up Wyatt’s lukewarm life.

Abby is thrilled when Roz temporarily returns to her job as bailiff, but must make things right when Roz starts ruffling everyone’s feathers. Dan co-opts Gurgs’ assistant.